Justice Review: 2. Utilitarianism

Summary

The Greatest Happiness Principle / Utilitarianism

The chapter begins with a story about 4 men on a boat. They get stranded. The 4 decide that one boy should die and become food for the other 3 to live. This prompts a utilitarian thought: is it justified to kill the one? A utilitarian might say that the 1 should die for the other 3. However, one may also say that it makes exception to murder, harming society in the long-term.

Then, the book introduces Jeremy Bentham. Bentham is regarded as the father of utilitarianism. He supports the greatest good for the greatest good. He doesn’t support individual rights or other theories that are not utilitarianism. He believes all discussion is nor whether to support utilitarianism, but how to. He proposed a system of beggars where beggars are sent to workplaces instead of sleeping on the ground. This was because, in his opinion, helping both parties: beggars and those who have to see beggars begging(More about Bentham in my other post dedicated to him).

Two objections are made here. One is on individual rights. By considering the total happiness of everyone, individual rights are often overlooked. Throwing Christians at lions was given as an example. We should not throw Christians at lions because Christians have rights. There is also a utilitarian reason not to, which is that people will be in fear that they will also be thrown one day.

The second objection is that it is quite difficult, or maybe even impossible, to calculate happiness. It is simply difficult to convert all pain and pleasure into one standard. The book gives an example of a Czech company that calculated the benefits of smoking, and claimed that they were greater than the harms smoking brought. This is called a cost-benefit analysis. There was a big backlash from those who thought the calculation underrated the value of life. Others simply think a price tag cannot be put on life.

John Stuart Mill is another influential thinker who developed utilitarianism. He adds more information, in an attempt to answer the criticism of utilitarianism, using utilitarian ideas. Mill first proposed the harm principle. One only has freedom when the freedom does not harm others. While this addition looks unrelated to utility, Mill disagrees. He believes respecting individual rights helps people in the long run. According to Mill, offering a corrective to prevailing opinion prevents it from hardening dogma and prejudice, allowing social improvement. A counter argument to this point is that there are situations where individual rights and happiness are deprioritized for the welfare of more people. Mill has a response, but outside the confines of utilitarian morality. Living confined by custom or convention is wrong. To achieve the highest end of human life, humans should be able to fully and freely develop themselves. Conformity is evil. Mill sees the importance of manners of action and that it is important for people to have character. This is not as consequential as Bentham’s theory.

One more addition Mill makes is the qualitative approach to happiness: there are higher pleasures and there are lower pleasures. This is judged by the preference of individuals who have fully experienced both choices. More people preferring one thing would mean it is of higher quality. An obvious objection that could be derived here is that more people may prefer lowly pleasures over noble ones. Mill rejects that. He says people may be tempted to choose lower pleasures sometimes. However, people are not willing to genuinely trade high pleasures for low pleasures, because of liberty, personal independence, and human dignity.

Bentham was the more consistent thinker. Mill was the more humane one.

Thoughts

The principle of utility looks good on paper, but raises more questions the more we look into it. It almost feels more noble and smart to be critics of utilitarianism and to support deontology or libertarianism. However, after some rumination, I support utilitarianism to a large extent.

The primary reason is the increase in happiness. People do not object to the idea. Rather, they find objections and counterexamples where utilitarian theory seems to be inhumane.

However, a lot of these theories can be objected to when applying utilitarianism in the long run. I will give an example. There are four people seeking help because they lack an organ, each requiring different ones. A person walks into the hospital for a health check. I would not take the organs of the person. I support deontology and libertarianism in a lot of cases too; that is one reason to not kill the man. However, from a utilitarian perspective, I should not. Then people would live in fear of being killed in hospitals. People would not get health checks. There would be riots and political unrest.

I also agree with Bentham on one more point. One must find another earth to stand on to move the earth. Many applications of other theories, such as libertarianism and deontology, are for happiness. Yes, we might not be enjoying welfare right away, possibly sacrificing it for others. Sometimes we are giving less advantages to the greater number of minorities. However, at the end of the day, the majority agrees to help the minority for a reason. If there is no reason, they will not do it. It is insufficient to conclude that the reason is for “human dignity” or “freedom”, in my opinion. Human dignity and freedom are important values because they augment pleasure. People feel happiness when they aim for social justice and are doing the right thing. Many are willing to sacrifice the short-term benefits for the happiness that they get from doing the right thing, especially when the short-term benefits come from the exploitation of others. I reject that everybody values money and other simple pleasures to a disproportionately high level. People also find happiness-possibly greater happiness-through higher values.

Of course, this thought may be wrong in some cases. I believe, in those cases, utilitarianism is wrong. Under the assumption that the greatest happiness harms minorities and certain groups of people, it should be rejected.

Leave a Comment