Justice Review 4: Markets and Morals

Hired Help / Markets and Morals

Summary

The free market is liked by many. It allows people to exercise freedom and increases utility for both buyers and sellers. Some criticisms of the free market are that it is not truly free and that some things cannot be sold for money. The book explores two scenarios: fighting wars and bearing children.

The method used in the US civil war to recruit people was controversial. It conscripted people, but people were allowed to hire other people to take their spot. Some people consider this unfair because it is a form of class discrimination. They say poor people are forced to serve the country in some way because it is the only way they can earn money. The rich would not potentially sacrifice their lives for the same amount of money.

This raises the question: Isn’t the voluntary army quite similar? Poor people are forced to join the army. It is not a true free choice.

Let’s explore the case for the voluntary army. Libertarians will argue that allowing people to choose whether they want to serve in the military or not protects their freedom and rights. Utilitarians will argue that those who serve gain happiness from the benefits they get, and those who do not serve gain happiness by not risking their lives and getting military protection. Despite more tax being paid, paying tax is less of a sacrifice than risking lives.

The first objection is the one already explained. People do not have a free choice.

The second objection argues that civic virtue is not maintained. Proponents believe that people have an obligation to serve their country. Jean-Jacques Rousseau argues for this in The Social Contract (1762). Some also argue that paid armies are less accountable and they patriotism.

Next, let’s look at another case. There was a couple that made a contract with a woman. The contract was that the woman would bear the child that the couple would get. The baby was from the man’s sperm. After the woman gave birth to the baby, she did not give the baby to the couple. They went to court. The first court ruled that the couple should get the baby. The second court ruled that the woman who gave birth should keep the baby.

The argument for the first option is that a deal is a deal. This will be further explained when the book discusses the works of John Rawls.

The second ruling can be supported for two reasons. First, it was not a free choice. The woman would not have known what she would feel like after she gave birth. She was not informed of the emotional attachments she would develop.

Second, some goods cannot be traded. It goes against human dignity to sell a human baby. It is trading a life, or at least the right to raise a life. In a civilized society, we do not tolerate that.

This was not just a one-time incident. People still practice this, albeit using more advanced technology that seems more humane. There are more cases where people get surrogacy from people in developing countries. This further raises the question of whether it being a free choice, as people lack the opportunity to earn money even more.

Thoughts

I disagree with quite a few points here. Let’s look at the military first.

I support the voluntary army.

Civic duty is absolute nonsense. As Locke argues, governments exist to protect the rights of people. There is a weak link between keeping that goal and keeping duty. If we can achieve safety with other methods, that is fine.

So is patriotism. People can judge the consequences. If the army is not doing well, there should be changes. There are more objective statistics that can be used to assess the performance of militaries.

Coercion is more convincing. However, serving the country is far from the only choice for the poor. Welfare is given. They can get a job that is easy to get. It is true that some differences in freedom exist. However, it still includes the voluntary choices of the poor. If that is there to a certain level, it’s sufficient. Capitalism is supposed to reward the rich.

What the poor want should also be considered. They want money. That is simple. There is a chance that the poor will get more monetary support, but that is only a chance. There are barriers we must consider, such as the voting power of the middle and rich classes.

Let’s weigh this against the alternative, which is conscription. Concerning the harms that some may get, a choice to inflict harm on everybody is made. This is difficult to justify. Weighing rights and freedom, we can see another reason to support the voluntary army. Some freedom is limited when choosing the voluntary army. However, much more rights are taken away by more stakeholders.

I support surrogacy.

I’m conflicted about free choice. It is true that those who give birth cannot foresee the emotional attachments they will develop. I still buy the point that they have enough freedom. They can be informed by experts and predict the outcome.

I disagree with the idea that there are things that cannot be traded. That is for the buyer and seller to decide. Government intervention is intrusive.

Let’s weigh this against the benefits. Big money can be earned by surrogate mothers. This is greater than the harm that mothers get from regretting. Another benefit is that couples can get their baby in a different way. This gives them new meaning in their lives, whcih is a great benefit.

Leave a Comment