Summary
History is often disappointing. Lots of countries have done so much wrong. The book gives some examples. The Nazis massacred a lot of Jews. Imperialist Japan killed a lot of Asians and were perpetrators of comfort women. Australian settlers were quick to segregate Aborigines. Slavery was led by the white people of America. They also annexed the Kingdom of Hawaii.
Professor Sandel introduces these examples for a reason. He asks, “Should we atone for the sins of our predecessors?”
The book explains the side that argues an apology is not due by the current people. A lot of writing, but it could be summarized as, “I have not committed the actions. I do not have responsibility. I support moral individualism.”
In fact, Locke, Kant, and Rawls seem to explain their theories from an individualist point of view.*(Check “Tangent”)
Locke: individuals have a natural right to property
Kant: individuals have autonomy and rationality
Rawls: consider what individuals would choose when under a veil of ignorance
The book then segues this dilemma into the discussion of the intervention of morality in politics. Aristotle supported this. Kant and Rawls did not. Many fear that if governments force moral ideas, some would disagree. Circling back to Kant and Rawls, they believe that rights are prior to good.
Kant and Rawls disagree with Aristotle because it does not prioritize freedom. Egalitarians and libertarians are also keen on freedom because, well, people are free, and also because it avoids controversies. However, Sandel supports a good world, over freedom.
Sandel says we are a part of a community that we cannot attach ourselves to. Alasdair MacIntyre attempts to give an answer. In his book After Virtue (1981), he says that human beings are storytelling beings. We live our lives as narrative quests. “I can only answer the question ‘What am I to do?’ if I can answer the prior question ‘Of what story or stories do I find myself a part?'” This asks, “Can I really explain who I am without talking about the communities that I am in?” MacIntyre and Sandel say no.
Rawls says our only obligations are natural duties that arise as citizens and the voluntary obligations we have put upon ourselves. Following MacIntyre’s view, one more obligation takes place.
Three Categories of Moral Responsibility
- Natural duties: universal; don’t require consent
- Voluntary obligations: particular; require consent
- Obligations of solidarity: particular; don’t require consent
Let’s skim through some scenarios.
Two people are drowning, one is your family member. Do you have a special obligation to save your family? Communitarians say yes.
You are attacking villages because your country asked you to. Do you have a special obligation to make your home village an exception? Communitarians say yes.
Ethiopians are suffering and Israelis saved Ethiopian Jews only. Is this justified? Communitarians say yes.
We are in the same community called the country. Is patriotism a virtue, then?
Why do people feel good for helping the border control of one’s country? Is it because they kept their communitarian virtue?
Maybe we should not discriminate against others just because they are not a part of our community. Or is it okay?
What if I know my brother plans to bomb bombs? Do I have an obligation to tell the police? What if I am the police? Then do I have an obligation?
Sandel makes it clear that he thinks keeping civic virtues as pursuing the common good should be prioritized over freedom.d
*Tangent: I mean… kinda? But it’s a bit weird when you consider it. For Locke, I agree. Kant, in his categorical imperative, uses universal application. This is an attempt to test if an action puts my interests over others, trying to make an unselfish choice. Rawls sacrifices well-off individuals to help the less advantaged. Yes, individuals make choices, but they do not get to make choices for themselves. This looks especially weird to me since Sandel’s opinion is not to support moral individualism, it is to support “communitarianism”. So the author putting weight on his antithesis, especially when it’s extremely debatable, is a little confusing.
I want to give my thoughts on the post for chapter 10 because I think the book is still building up.