A Hello
Hello, everyone. WordPress sent an email saying that there was a technical problem with my blog. I don’t see any problems, but I really don’t want all my posts to get deleted.
Introduction
Affirmative action. Do you support it? It’s a striking moral thought. It’s so thought-provoking. In fact, if affirmative action comes out as a BP debate motion, 5 teams can be made for the same side. I want to specifically talk about affirmative action in university applications.
What do we need to consider?
1 Discrimination in application and subjective tests.
Are minorities getting low scores because of traits beyond their scope of control? Should we make reparations for that?
2 Repaying for past wrongdoings.
Did we harm minorities back then? Should the people of right now pay for that? What’s the reason? Because majorities have blood money? Because majorities are part of the community that once oppressed minorities?
3 Promoting diversity on campus.
Should campuses promote diversity?
4 Applications are often decided by factors that are beyond the control of students.
Is that okay? Can universities do what they want because they are private institutions??
5 Roles of universities.
What is the role of universities?
6 Helping minorities.
Does affirmative action help minorities? Don’t they go on to live a life that is not as good as those who applied normally anyway?
7 Making long-term solutions.
Isn’t promoting equal opportunities more important?
8 Reparation for current oppression.
Aren’t minorities still oppressed?
9 Harms to Asians.
Aren’t Asians harmed by affirmative action policies?
10 Exceptions.
Aren’t there a bunch of exceptions? What about the white people who only had ancestors who never owned slaves? What about the white people who had ancestors who were white slaves?
11 Other factors play an even bigger role.
Skin color? Isn’t that just one thing? What about wealth?
12 Does this debate even matter? Won’t universities always say, “It is for diversity.”, to escape controversy? Won’t majorities always say, “I don’t have any duty now”? Won’t minorities always say, “I have a smaller chance to succeed”?
My Opinion
Affirmative action should happen, performed on a small scale. However, I think wealth is the biggest standard.
Why am I ignoring slavery? I’m not. It is because economic advantages are still accrued. Let’s use slavery as an example. If the ancestors were slaves and therefore earned little money by force, and those economic disadvantages ran straight down the family to the people living in current society, the descendants deserve compensation. This is because they were harmed by factors out of their control.
Then, what if the ancestors were slaves, but a descendant of that slave (and an ancestor of the current person) reversed that situation, and managed to be rich? I believe that the student who lives in the current world is not entitled to affirmative action (aka compensation). This is because their ancestors earning the money and reversing the situation was also luck.
So what’s the conclusion? The wealth of high school graduates is not decided by themselves. Even if some are, I’m talking about the wealth that they didn’t earn, and even including the wealth they earned if it is clear that they earned it through their circumstances (e.g. they got a job because of their parents who had lots of networks). Therefore, wealth is an arbitrary advantage. Poverty is an arbitrary disadvantage. Therefore, it’s important to compensate for that. The economic disadvantages caused by racial injustice are also compensated in this system.
To some extent, however, I think it’s hard for students to cultivate their academic merit because of the discrimination they get in society. Because old people are still living, black students, Asian students, Hispanic students, etc. are still getting discriminated against. I think race should be one factor to give an advantage. I don’t think it should be a major factor, since discrimination is not major (really defines, how you define major, though). Furthermore, I disagree with having a fixed number of minorities joining. This is not a proper calculation. Even if, let’s say, Hispanic students have less academic ability. That’s not a reason to blindly reject white students. If a white student is substantially better, they still deserve a spot.
Let’s talk about diversity now. I don’t care about diversity. In fact, I think it’s wrong that universities care. The justification is that we need to consider the social position of universities. I acknowledge that universities are a place to learn and a place to prepare for society. Regardless of the intentions of the university, or what they want it to be, the fact is university determines the future of students. That’s the bigger role of universities. I’m not saying that’s justified. It might not be. But that’s how society works. And I don’t think it’s possible to change. In 2020, workers with a bachelor’s degree had median weekly earnings of $1,305, while those with a high school diploma earned $781. The unemployment rate for individuals with a bachelor’s degree was 5.5%, compared to 9.0% for those with only a high school diploma. Graduates from top institutions like Princeton University and Massachusetts Institute of Technology had a mid-career median pay of $189,400. Similarly, Stanford University graduates had a median mid-career pay of $177,500. By comparison, mid-career median salaries for graduates from less prestigious universities, such as Weber State University and Temple University, were significantly lower at $72,400 and $78,700, respectively. When universities have this much power in society, and over the lives of people, they have a responsibility. A responsibility to pick students with academic merit. As soon as they exploit the race of students for a different goal, they are abusing their power.
I reject the communitarian perspective. Just because I’m white, I don’t have a moral obligation to feel sorry for slaves. Yes, economic advantages have accrued. But that’s all fixed in a policy where financial status is taken into consideration. It’s not even really true that people feel proud of their own race. Maybe they’re just proud of their country and not race. Even if they do feel proud of their race, that doesn’t matter. They can feel proud. They can reject slavery and hate that. There is a weak link between feeling proud and having moral obligations to compensate.
I think this debate is really mixed with personal bias. It’s because both sides are so strong, and people support the side that fits their needs. I still think it’s good to have some debate. Maybe some people are willing to change their opinion, even if it does not fit with their own advantages.
What do you think? It’s really hard to come to a conclusion. Regardless, it can cultivate your moral thought.