Introduction
Guided debate is an activity I aim to do regularly, starting with this post. This is how it works.
- I find a high-quality debate video, something I can learn from
- I pick which role I want to be
- I read the motion and prepare for it
- I listen to the debate and prepare my speech accordingly
- I listen to the rest of the debate
I’m doing this activity because I think one of the best ways to learn debate is analyzing speeches that are better than yours to learn from them. Please note that this is not educational material. It is simply to document myself learning debate and encourage myself to watch debate videos frequently. Watching the debate video itself would be much more educational.
I picked a WUDC debate because I need to do a BP debate tomorrow and want to prepare for it. I chose the debate round with this motion because I believe religion is a debate theme that I need improvements in, as I am an atheist.
The info slide and motion of this debate is:
“Semifinals has an info slide:
For the purposes of this debate, religions that “center the self” embrace human existence and individual experiences as special. Believers are asked to consider their choices and experiences, struggles, and connection to God as uniquely important and a path to salvation.
In contrast, religions that “reject the self” explicitly reject the idea that human existence and individual experiences are special. Believers are asked to accept individual experiences as temporary and unimportant, and individuality as an illusion that causes unhappiness.
The motion for Semifinals reads:
This House Prefers religions that “center the self” to religions that “reject the self””
This is the link to the original video: https://youtu.be/h_1T2s-DfOE?si=xBkrXkucfGrqsDhG
I chose to be Member of Government.
In this blog, I’ll share the debate prep I have done, the flow that I have written, the speech I have written, and the video of me debating. Please note that these are not well organized. I am sharing the versions that I have written with the time constraints of debate. Since the purpose of this activity is to document my debate, not improving my ability to tidy my notes, I felt that this is more appropriate.
The purpose of sharing the flow of the debate (i.e. the notes I took while listening) is not to summarize the speeches given. Rather, it is just to show that I have listened to the speeches.
My Prep
This is the debate preparation I have done for Closing Government before watching any speeches.
“gov ideas spill
able to value own life and find value in that
religion: believing in god
viewing the world
tied with wars
tied with conflicts
tied with afterlife:
likely to bring more to the table: feel that my contributions are essential to the religion
religion tells u that whenever u are doing something, that is either moral or immoral, helping or harming the world in a certain way
me liking God means a lot to me
principly correct: values mutual respect
able to control self to be moral and fulfill purpose of religion
likely for me to take action: me to donate to charity
me to be nice to my acquaintances
being special is actually a reason to respect others
if others are also nothing, then there is no reason to respect them
all i need to do is ignore them in the opp’s world, bc even the other believer or my friend or parent is simply a part of sth, not an indiv
therefore, if others are special indivs i respect them more
stakeholders
people in need
God
me
people around me
other believers
pastors
falls into depression
i would have to accept the fact that i am nothing
i am merely a part of a larger thing called hinduism or christianity
a part of a machine is not what i want to be, but i am forced to be
living productively: as a means of developing self
-> focus on well being
this is evident
some religions tell ppl to be diligent:
some religions acts as a philosophy for happiness: you should seize the moment now
-> even if untrue, compare to the actions i will do when i think i mean i am nothing, then will only focus on an afterlife that realistically we do not know if it will exist or not
this allows people to have a life of own
i can become a religious man, and I can also become a man that likes my family
that likes football
that likes steak
and feels fulfillment from my job of being a programmer
why religion is likely to do this
-> many religions tell people what to do
e,g, god created man to live: for us to adhere to what god has said, we live on, instead of biting our fingers until death
this is more likely to exist on an individual centered religion
this escapes the government from manipulating u
e.g. opps world looks like thailand where buddhist ideas tell them to be idle so that the king does whatever he wants
why reject the self is bad:
idea becomes depressing: very little reason to believe in the religion
what would OO say:
able to unite instead of fighting
actually unite as one
this is the purpose of religion: to come together and believe in sth
other values like family relations and captialism is a reason that people develop individualistic ideas
way of getting out of depression: actually gives meaning in my life
it is inherently impossible and scientifically proven that i cannot find meaning in life as a human
-> like hobbes say, i am just a piece of meat
My Flow
“PM flow
Hook
suppresses the self -> alienable is better
- diverse human experience -> source of the divinity is human
- life is positive
- primacy and choice: good and real: self sacrifice is choice
- agency
- more respect
- sexual minority
- women
- highlighted as path to divinity
- accepts differences
- opp tells people to be stop individuality
- meaningful and explain relationship with god
- personal acceptance of self
- opp’s benefits are not given to ppl who need them
- religion can be an oppressive structure
- on prop cares about individuals
- on opp, connecting god to self: seek it out from higher powers: use it for own gain
- 3 harms
- racial minority
- defer authority
- authoritarian govs
- internal suppression
- have something broken in self
- born with different preference
- weigh this: vulnerable groups, cannot fight back
- remove from solace
- religion of opp: vulnerable to authoritarian govs
- tyranny cannot be mitigated: coming from u
- world on opp: cannot be defended
- come together and helps poor
- makes better for indiv
- if suffering is temporary: can justifiy the spiritual happiness
- obligatory that suffer
- soup kitchens
- build things
- have self that is dignified
- nothing underneath
- largest charity and aid
- not just physical health but spiritual health: solace and happiness
- makes better for indiv
categorically: center of self, center of the debate
LO
framing and charac is wrong
: independent of other narratives
promotes self, capitalism like biological needs
devoid of religious influence
dependent on drive power
ability to control resources
these natural drives for preservation already exists
maybe this is not imp
multiple narratives is a win
diff degrees of life
some people win and some dont end in semis
getting individual success, can subscribe to other views
maybe sometimes u can get sth out of religion
quality of life
even if not true, rest of case would be not true
alt will be good enough anyway
accept women and minorities
POI: icons are other
R: why should it all be homogenous
S: acceptance of others
R:
- why is it done by religion
- why would i change myself
- blamed for choices that contradict religion
- individualized choice
- homosexualities is bad can be changed
- u choosing to be gay is not an attack on religion:
- in opp we dont judge, so it is okay
- accept more
constructive
birth lottery
iq
interacts
pure randomness of molecular atoms
prioritizing the experience on gov
privilege maximize: less incentive to give up
realize experience matter
you need to maximize with god
donate millions to build god
oppressed, end up suffering: some end up with good experience, some end with good, some end up with bad
blame self for not doing enough
individual: want to see incremental improvement, structural barriers, blame self
exploit and tell u: uncertainty of the god thing, coerce into doing more and more
-> you are forced to be an individual
DPM
there are equally other narratives for others
nationalism and family
way in which they view life: they are vulneerable
individuals have direct authority, X need mediator
vulnerable people: X feel like impose ideas
they are more oppressive in general
motion is not retrospective
even if homophobia existed, even if community believes in that, religion can reverse it
they do not mention: all these other narratives cannot create existential crisis
people are connected
personal reflection: maybe god came here for a reason
better than thinking life is unnecessary
you value your life actually
god values individual experience
david already says that people rally together that human experiences is valuable
need to believe that human experiences are
if incidental, worse quality of lives
easier to attribute to the real and genuine struggles
how we react: need better accommodation
if recognize divine process, that the experiences are diverse, can be more respected
DLO speech
OG assumes that all experiences are valued
operates in a world that exist today
nobody is born as an expert of religion
you value choices using religion as litmous paper for judgment
ask if religion allow this
ability to judge someone else for choice: think it is a sin to be aberration, but not that imp compared to gov world
priest
prioritize own
i need to maximize my relationship,
open up doorway of exploitation
more abuse
way in seeing others change
judge anyone
making aggressive choices become most imp
hate other people,
i matter the most
abstractly find happiness
lot of control over other things
material wealth and religiosity
what about my individual
bc X enough time to pray cannot contribute
Video MG Speech
you faced suffering, you viewing life, can improve your life
need reason to be alive
many ppl suffer right now
reasons why people given poor lot
capitalism exploits
continue to suffer and starve
agency is provided
4 mechs
- internal locus of control
- you must be agnostic
- belief that doing sth is enough
- can control self
- constructive claim
- tells where u are
- individualistic narratives exist, but capitalism is diff
- meritocratic system, the value u have is contingent to the money u have
- if dont win, tell u that u failed in life
- religion is diff: community oriented
- less based on immutable characteristics
- if wealthy, donate
- hierarchy is symmetrical, but might as well care for self
- you can assign urself happiness
- even if think determinism is there, can make change, make steps, try to help community
- despair is stronger than suffering
- marginal change for suffering is harder on your side
- suffering has physical elements
- suffering is relational element
- kid is suffering, may not have same sufferings as u
POI: what if u dont buy in
R: many ppl still will
what do we do
even if condition is bad, individual contribution matters
e.g. hinduism
what u do comes back in another thing, sometimes in afterlife
same for bad situation, past life is at fault
MO Speech
3 things
- not retrospective, but it is an assessment
- intepretations of religious structures are a big part of the debate
- OG’s ideas about god depends on the mediator
- what matters is the moral sense
- has to do with CG, X know the agency of choice
- internal things, can fight for other things
- morality and virtue
- can fight that for others, not self
why does it forms religious structure
this is a structure that changes human experience, about whether lives are valuable or not
humanity questions
specific beliefs: changes structures of religions
idea of struggle and overcoming
seen more of the world
see the levels of power
seizing power -> no-one understands interpretation of religion
epistemically, not just in the speciality of an individual, it is for the whole structure
not one guy
hierarchy: fewer cancels telling on a sunday
more checks and balance
elite capture
difficult
acquisition of power: the hiding scandals do not happens
more liberalization of time
can get own beliefs
can choose some things, instead of choosing nothing
whole point is individuals
two weighing
- x engage with theological doctrine
structures and things: outside religion
secular and queer people
people impacted are manipulated
- axiom: does rejection of self mean altruism?
it just means taching of beliefs
beats OG
GW
OO ignores the suffering
solace through religion is a priori
lead to us living better
OG just flags agency
but they just say politics
OG says that u are special
we are unique bc
sense of control is uniquely good
positive outlook in life
try to compare
centering into capitalism
easiest way to achieve
coerced to do bad things: they just say it is bad bc it is old
religions have incentive to change: can tell to center self
deal with the hierarchical argument
autonomous decisions
choices made
even if all is not true
solace outweighs material harm
S: could end up stopping wars
even if say that, the comparative looks on ur side
there is no agitation to prevent suffering, on ur side suffering is internalized
dealing with CO arg of hierarchy
they say control of religion is bad
OO and CO is flawed: net hierarchy is intrinsically bad is not mech
we say it is inclusive so will evolve
church educates
transition to case
even if relevant to improve
regardless of that, even if X care about physical suffering, care about others around you
people in position that seek to prove: if agnostic, never change
groundbreaking movements
feel it is gods purpose
3 reasons
- more change
- happy
- despair is worse that suffering
OW speech
CG broadly focuses on agency
- comparative is not free will itself
it is to say still have control over things
- have free will
should i spend more time on OG or CG? presumed by free will
rationalize my decision
changes are good in long run
reduce capacity to exploit ppl
able to insert self
choose what u want to take
less hierarchy
checks and balances
reduce incentive within religion
do not manipulate people
if incidental,
say my individual experiences are imp
majoritarian identities
dissuade those unlike u
help others
morality existing
counervnance is in rejection
leverage of power
less ability to religion as a power, have checks and balances
POI: if both subjective, also untrue that (cuts off way too much)
incentive to exploit should be the comparative
there are other narrative
OO is marginal of how deliver case
we have the better way
able to have fulfillment and make it close to you
access the escapism more”
My Speech
My MG Speech
wrong characterization that relgiions only tell u how to pray and how to be moral
rather they give u a whole guideline of life
DPM implies this: they say it is a way they view life
characterization:
religions have two nuances: valuing the current life and valuing the afterlife
if centers self: value the current life
-> care about me now
if reject self: likely to gather around for the good, for the later, where it is the after life
or if not for the after life, just something else than me in general
general describes whether it is more oppressive or allowing of life
S: i matter the most in this religious, therfore I care more about myself more than others like minorities
R:
- this is an assumption,
- if i am special, and the religion tells that to everyone
- i know that others are special too
S: poor ppl feel bad bc cannot contribute
R:
- so rare that religions will actually hate the poor bc they have not contribtued enough
- god would understand
living productively: as a means of developing self
-> focus on well being
this is evident
some religions tell ppl to be diligent:
some religions acts as a philosophy for happiness: you should seize the moment now
-> even if untrue, compare to the actions i will do when i think i mean i am nothing, then will only focus on an afterlife that realistically we do not know if it will exist or not
this allows people to have a life of own
i can become a religious man, and I can also become a man that likes my family
that likes football
that likes steak
and feels fulfillment from my job of being a programmer
why religion is likely to do this
-> many religions tell people what to do
e,g, god created man to live: for us to adhere to what god has said, we live on, instead of biting our fingers until death
this is more likely to exist on an individual centered religion
especially imp bc can create change in developing world: i need a better life
weighing against opening gov:
deadlock happened:
oppression likely to happen anyway: lot of people are using religion as a mere plea to be racist and sexist
smaller number of stakeholders
weighing against the second arg that PM says and DPM drops: many charities exist anyway
we take OG impacts: they use words like “agency”, “tells meaning of life”, but that was vague
we give better mechanisms
their claim is that you realize that your life is valuable bc the religion says so
-> some people may by, but may just think that it is a weird saying of God
we give more mechanisms: ppl can have a life
weigh against OO:
exploitation: i can say no, i have the right to
especially if they exploit, that would be contradictory to the values
even if i am exploited, you are infinitely exploited if u urself does not exist